Thursday, July 28, 2016

Your Rights in Assisted Living and in a Nursing Home:

     Helping an elderly relative move into an assisted living residence can be an emotional and worrisome time for everyone involved. When you or someone you know makes the decision to live in an assisted living facility, you trust that facility to perform certain duties to keep you healthy and safe. Because the elderly are expected to live longer and longer lives as medicine progresses, one can expect to live in an assisted living residence for a number of years. As one reaches the age of retirement and beyond, their body grows more delicate and susceptible to infection and disease. In addition, injuries resulting from falls can be devastating and may affect the injured person for the rest of his or her life. Depending on the situation, one might be able to gain compensation for injuries due to medical malpractice or negligence by the assisted living facility.


     First, it is important to make a clear distinction between an assisted care facility and a nursing home. An assisted care facility is one that provides housing, food, transportation, and in-house monitoring to its residents. Assisted living facilities also develop individual plans for each of their residents which are bound to change over time. On the other hand, nursing homes provide skilled medical care to those who needs it such as the disabled or ill. Nursing homes also provide housing and health services. Like assisted care facilities, nursing homes also develop individual care plans for their residence; however, these plans are largely medically based. The difference between these two entities can be determined by the level of medical care they provide. In the case of nursing homes, the failure to meet the needs of a resident may result in liability under medical malpractice, negligence, and/or New York Public Health Law § 2801 - d.

     New York Public Health Law § 2801 - d states that, “If the residential health care facility such, as a nursing home, deprives a patient of any right or benefit he or she may have under the law, then the institution is liable for any injuries that the patient suffers because of the deprovation of any right or benefit.” This is includes any benefits that are put in place for the wellbeing of the patient. This also includes state regulations and requirements of health care facilities. If a health care facility is found to be liable for patient’s injury, that patient should receive compensation to cover the damages suffered.  This payment will be no less than 25% of the patient’s payments to the health care facility. At this point and time, this law is most often applied to nursing homes.

    Injures do occur at  long-term residential facility. Some of the most common injuries include those incurred from falls and bed sores. The risk of infection causes bed sores to be particularly dangerous to patients. There is a Quality of Health law that addresses bed sores and how facilities should prevent and treat them. It states that when a patient without bed sores is admitted into a facility, they are not to develop bed sores unless it was unavoidable. If a bed sore does develop, it is a facility’s duty to provide treatment to the patient for the purpose of healing it. Other claims can be made based on emotional harm, financial loss, or death.


     When disputing a claim, a nursing home or long-term care facility must establish that they took every reasonable measure to prevent the injury from happening. Before admitting a loved one into a nursing home or long-term care facility, always inspect the environment in which they will be living. Note the quality and care that residents receive at the facility. In the resident’s room, take note of any loose rugs or objects that stick out at odd angles. Make sure public areas and bathrooms of the facility are well lit to minimize the chance of your loved one tripping and suffering a serious fall. If you find a potential injury hazard, you have to choices; either search for another residential facility or nursing home, or notify the facility’s management of the situation immediately.  

     A nursing home or long-term residence facility may also be held liable if they do not properly adhere to the resident’s plan of care. If the needs of a resident are ignored, a facility may be charged with neglect. Errors in providing medication, or providing the wrong medication to a patient can result in a liability claim. Before admitting a relative to a long-term residential facility, it is important to recognize that he or she has the right to take legal action against the facility of they are injured as a result of negligence, malpractice, or neglect. A facility can to punish or otherwise discriminate against a resident for exercising their right to take legal action. In some cases, a resident may not be able to act on his or her own behalf due to mental or physical incapacitation. When this happens, a legally appointed individual will act on the resident’s behalf.  This individual should be someone who the resident trusts and who is trustworthy, usually a close family member. 

     Currently, it is debated as to whether claims of malpractice or negligence are appropriate when applied to nursing homes. Claims will vary from case to case, but standard rule is that malpractice claims address the actions of medical care professionals or medical procedures. For example, incorrect medication distribution would most likely fall under a medical malpractice claim. On the other hand, if a patient trips on something that could or should have been moved out of their path, a liability claim would most likely fall under negligence.

     When defending a negligence claim, one must prove that the facility owed a duty to the resident and failed to fulfill it. Medical malpractice claims are slightly more difficult to apply to long-term care facilities because an attorney must consult and obtain documentation from a medical expert or an appropriate physician clearly indicating why the facility is at fault.


     If you are seriously considering admitting a loved one into a long-term care facility or a nursing home, remember that the wellbeing and health of that loved one depends on the quality of care they receive at the new residence. It is not a decision to be made lightly and involves a great amount of trust on the resident’s behalf. If you or a loved one have suffered an injury at a nursing home or long-term care facility, you may be able to receive compensation for these damages. For more information, contact Poissant, Nichols, Grue, and Vanier at:

367 West Main Street                                                                        45 Market Street
Malone, New York 12953                                                                 Potsdam, New York 13676

Phone: (518) 483-1440
Toll Free: 1-800-924-3529

-Joseph Nichols
-Paul Nichols




1 comment:

  1. At Wagners our entire team has a proven track record for cases involving motor vehicle accidents, fatalities, medical malpractice, birth trauma and other serious incidents.

    ReplyDelete